Rome, 21 September 2008 – They speak Italian, eat Italian and cheer for Italy’s soccer stars, but they are not Italian. In fact, it’s hard to say what they are.
Thousands of people are living in Italy without citizenship or identity documents from any country. Most were citizens of countries that no longer exist, such as Yugoslavia or the Soviet Union. But they never received citizenship from the countries that replaced their broken-up nations, and they also fail to meet the requirements to become citizens of Italy.
It’s hard to know how many there are because they survive on the margins of society, but the Sant’Egidio Community, a Rome-based Catholic organization, puts the number at about 10,000 to 15,000. They are often hunted by authorities, who try to deport them as illegal immigrants even though they have nowhere to go.
Life in limbo can be particularly harsh for those who were born and went to school in Italy. Once they turn 18, they become little more than illegal immigrants under the law.
“We are not Yugoslav; we are not Italian. We are like clouds,” said Toma Halilovic, who lives with his parents, wife and children in two containers in a makeshift camp on the outskirts of Rome.
Halilovic, 26, was born in the Italian capital to Yugoslav parents who came here legally in the 1970s. He went through compulsory basic schooling, made friends with local children and picked up a passion for the capital’s AS Roma soccer team.
When he turned 18, he thought he would receive citizenship. Children born in Italy to foreigners do not automatically receive citizenship, but they can claim it at ages 18 to 19 if they have lived in the country continuously and legally.
Halilovic said his application was turned down on a technicality: He was not registered as a resident at birth because at the time it was not required by law.
“They told me I was born in transit,” he said. “What does that mean? This is my country.”
In some cases, parents do not register children at birth because they have lost citizenship of their own countries of origin and cannot renew their Italian residency permits, said Paolo Morozzo della Rocca, a professor of immigration law at the University of Urbino, in central Italy.
Many of the nearly invisible people in Italy are Gypsies from the former Yugoslavia. Their lack of identity papers and a work permit gives them little opportunity to study, get a job and leave the poor encampments that house much of Italy’s Gypsy population of 150,000.
One solution for those like Halilovic is to be officially declared stateless. Under a 1954 U.N. convention, those recognized as such get a special passport, permission to stay and work in Italy, and a fast track to citizenship.
The U.N. High Commissioner for Refugees says that in 2007, governments recognized 886 stateless people in Italy, 948 in France, 4,461 in the Netherlands and 9,091 in Germany. France has set up a government office to investigate statelessness claims and says it usually takes about six months.
But there’s a catch-22 situation in Italy: The Interior Ministry requires a residency permit to recognize people as stateless. And a residency permit cannot be obtained without a valid passport, which stateless people do not have. The Interior Ministry declined to comment.
The only alternative is to sue the ministry in a civil court, which can take at least three years, Morozzo della Rocca said. He noted that most people without documents lack the time and money to go to court.
“Italy is being dishonest in applying the convention,” he said.
Interior Minister Roberto Maroni recently said the government plans to grant citizenship to abandoned Gypsy children born in Italy. But humanitarian groups say the real issue is speeding up the process that gives stateless people their rights.
One problem is the difficulty of distinguishing between those who are truly without citizenship and clandestine migrants who get rid of their papers after entering Italy, hoping to avoid deportation, said Oliviero Forti, head of the immigration office at the Catholic charity Caritas.
“For some it’s a plan: They tear up their documents and take advantage of the situation,” Forti said. “But there are also those who were born in our country, lived here and suddenly find out they are illegals.”
Source: Associated Press